Original Source

Petition for a Writ of Certiorari

Yes

Supreme Court of the United States

National Pork Producers Council & American Farm Bureau Federation (Petitioners), v. Karen Ross, et al, (Respondents)

27 SEP 2021

21-468

Posted on

Summary

The National Pork Producers Council (NPPC) and the American Farm Bureau Federation (AFBF) present their arguments to the Supreme Court urging a review of the Ninth Circuit’s judgment stating that they failed to plead Proposition 12 violates the dormant Commerce Clause. 

The plaintiffs argue that Proposition 12 violates the dormant Commerce Clause in two ways. First, it regulates wholly out-of-state commerce; a pig moves through multiple facilities outside California as it is raised, and the products resulting from its slaughter are sold across the United States. Second, the plaintiffs assert that Proposition 12 fails the “balancing test of Pike v. Bruce Church, Inc., 397 U.S. 137 (1970).” They attribute part of this failure to the proposition being based on a human health rationale “so patently false that California has declined to defend it.” Once this rationale is removed, they argue Proposition 12 rests otherwise only on “philosophical preferences about conduct occurring almost entirely outside California.” Consequently, their argument concludes that the reasons supporting Proposition 12 do not outweigh the “wrenching effect of the law on interstate commerce.”

In this document, the plaintiffs have prepared background information on Proposition 12, an overview of the national pork production industry (e.g., sow housing in the U.S., the process of raising piglets for slaughter), and  information on the impacts of Proposition 12 on pork production and pricing. The plaintiffs then present their reasons for why the Supreme Court should grant their petition.

Proposition 12 makes it a criminal and civil violation to sell pork in California unless the pig it comes from was born to a sow—an adult female—that was housed with 24 square feet of space and in conditions that allow the sow to turn around freely without touching her enclosure. Hardly any commercially-bred sows in the United States are housed with 24 square feet of space per sow, even those raised in group pens; and farmers almost universally keep sows in individual pens that do not comply with Proposition 12 during the period between weaning and confirmation of pregnancy, for animal health and business reasons.

Petitioners’ complaint (App., infra, 147a-233a) alleges that Proposition 12 violates the dormant Commerce Clause in two ways. 

First, it is impermissibly extraterritorial. California imports 99.87% of its pork. Because of the nature of the pork industry and its product—a pig progresses through multiple facilities outside California as it is raised, and is processed into many different cuts of meat that are sold across the country—Proposition 12 in practical effect regulates wholly out-of-state commerce. It requires massive and costly alteration to existing sow housing nationwide, necessitates either reduction of herd sizes or building of new facilities to meet its space mandates, raises prices in transactions with no California connection, drives farms out of business and promotes industry consolidation, and will be policed by intrusive inspections of out-of-state farms conducted by California’s agents. If any law violates the dormant Commerce Clause’s extraterritoriality principle because of its practical effects on commerce in other states, it is Proposition 12—but the Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal in large part because it deems that principle virtually a “dead letter.” App., infra, 19a. Given this Court’s “broad language” endorsing an extraterritoriality limit on state power, affected parties need a clear answer to the question whether that doctrine is indeed, as the Ninth Circuit seems to believe, “‘overbroad * * * dicta’ [that] can be ignored” (id. at 7a), or instead is an important component of our federalism.

Second, petitioners allege that Proposition 12 fails the balancing test of Pike v. Bruce Church, Inc., 397 U.S. 137 (1970). The law is based on a human health rationale so patently false that California has declined to defend it. Proposition 12 rests otherwise only on philosophical preferences about conduct occurring almost entirely outside California. Neither rationale out-weighs the wrenching effect of the law on interstate commerce.

The United States and its Department of Agriculture (USDA) share these views. They told the Ninth Circuit that the “‘critical inquiry’” under Healy v. Beer Institute, 491 U.S. 324, 336 (1989), is “‘whether the practical effect of the regulation is to control conduct beyond the boundaries of the State’” and that the “district court erred by dismissing the complaint” under that standard. U.S. Am. Br. at 1 (ECF 23). The United States provided four examples of how Proposition 12 disrupts elements of the interstate pork market of special concern to the federal government: Agricultural Marketing Service reporting of hog prices, which is the basis of much market pricing nationwide; administration of the Emergency Food Assistance Program; the purchasing power of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program; and compromising of farm biosecurity measures, which imposes burdens on USDA’s Animal Plant and Health Inspection Service. U.S. Br. at 2-5.

In addition, the United States explained, Proposition 12 is based on “an improper purpose”— banning pork imports “based solely on a desire to prevent what California considers animal cruelty that is occurring entirely outside the State’s borders.” U.S. Br. at 2. Because California advances no “legitimate local interest” (id. at 18), petitioners’ Pike challenge also should not have been dismissed.

In labelling the Healy line of cases dicta that can be ignored, the Ninth Circuit has undermined our federalist system, as 20 States explained below. Proposition 12’s extraterritorial reach threatens other states’ sovereignty, including their “decisions not to impose burdensome animal-confinement requirements on their farmers.” States’ Am. Br. at 16 (ECF 22). An Ohio law illustrates the point. Ohio expressly permits sow farmers to do what Proposition 12 forbids —to confine sows in breeding pens post-weaning until a new pregnancy is confirmed. Ohio Admin. Code 901:12-8-02(G)(4), (5). And Proposition 12, these States agree, has the impermissible effect of regulating “multiple transactions occurring wholly in other States—such as farm procurement and production, sale to distributors, and slaughter and packing”—before any transaction occurs in California. States’ Am. Br. at 14. 

Five trade groups, representing a broad swath of American industry, likewise urged that our Nation’s “foundational limits” on a state’s power over out-of-state conduct require reversal, lest state overreach “fracture[s] national markets.” Am. Br. of National Association of Manufacturers et al. at 4-5 (ECF 21).

The Ninth Circuit’s dormant Commerce Clause jurisprudence has gone off track. In conflict with other circuits, most notably the Seventh Circuit, and with this Court’s Healy line of cases, the Ninth Circuit has so narrowed the scope of the extraterritoriality doctrine that plausible allegations that a state law has “dramatic upstream effects,” forces “pervasive changes to the pork production industry nationwide,” and causes substantial “cost increases to market participants and customers” everywhere, fail to state a claim. App., infra, 18a, 20a. This Court should grant certiorari to clarify that basic principles of our federalism require a different result.